Alternative Pickle for Brass and Nickel Silver

Last year I wrote a post on pickling sterling silver with a mixture of vinegar and salt, a more eco-friendly alternative to pickling with Sparex. I'm still using this method for sterling, but have moved onto something else for brass and nickel silver.

While vinegar and salt worked okay with brass, it often left a hard-to-remove pink film on the surface, which I'd have to remove by sanding. A big pain.

After some digging, I found a better method, again, using common household supplies: vinegar and hydrogen peroxide, aka Peracetic Acid!

Peracetic Acid is used to disinfectant surfaces and even food, like fruits and veggies and raw meat. Pardon my hyperbole, but it works miracles on brass and nickel. Even commercial solutions like Sparex don't clean these metals as well as a vinegar and hydrogen peroxide mix!

Here's what I do:  

  • In a glass or plastic bowl or jar, mix two parts distilled white vinegar with one part hydrogen peroxide
  • After soldering, submerge your piece in the mixture until all oxidation is removed. Use tongs.* Give it at least 20 minutes.
  • You can swish the piece around every now and then. (I don't know if agitation actually helps, but it feels like it does!)
  • Remove your piece using tongs, rinse it off, and voila--your metal is clean!
  • The surface of the brass will often look crystallized. Remedy this by gently polishing the piece with steel wool or buffing with very fine sand paper.
  • Finish as usual.

*Even though Peracetic Acid is used in food cleaners, disinfectants, etc. I recommend using it with caution. Use the mixture in a ventilated space and use tongs when handling your piece.

Here's a before-and-after of the first piece I pickled. I left it in for about 15-20 minutes. The mixture will turn blue, and if you're pickling several pieces, it'll turn an even brighter blue than what you see in the photo below.


Unfortunately, the mixture isn't reusable, so I recommend pickling in batches.  This seems to work awhile, actually! I reuse the solution until it turns bright blue and cloudy. For disposal, I dilute the mixture with water and run it down the drain, or I let it sit on my back porch until it evaporates.  I'm not clear on the safest method for disposal, so if you know something, please share your thoughts in the comments!

I hope this helps!

Happy Spring,

Alternative Metals Tips for Soldering Copper and Brass from Jewelry Making Daily

Bill Sealy's Pickle Formulas